Blogs -Tesla Sells 33% Of Vehicles Below Average Cost, BYD Pulls Ahead

Tesla Sells 33% Of Vehicles Below Average Cost, BYD Pulls Ahead


November 14, 2023

author

Beth Kindig

Lead Tech Analyst

This article was originally published on Forbes on Nov 9, 2023,09:23pm EST

BYD more than doubled Tesla’s China sales in October as Tesla’s sales slipped on a month-over-month basis, while NEV startups showed strong sales numbers across the board. China’s new energy vehicle (NEV) industry continues to exhibit solid momentum, with September seeing NEV sales rise about +22% YoY and October estimated to see around +34% YoY growth. As a whole, China is expected to once again be the primary driver of global EV sales this year, with volumes forecast to reach or exceed 8.5 million units, or more than 60% of the projected 14 million global volume.

Tesla has been in the spotlight recently — its margins have contracted significantly over the past few quarters as it prioritizes price cuts. China is Tesla’s most important market as it currently represents the highest remaining total addressable market (TAM), therefore the recent weakness is not something to ignore, especially as domestic rivals pick up their pace of growth.

Sign up for I/O Fund's free newsletter with gains of up to 221% - Click here

BYD Trumps Tesla in China as Sales Stagnate

BYD’s delivery numbers have shown tremendous growth in Q3 and the start of Q4, as opposed to Tesla’s stagnation as consumer demand looks to be shifting in favor of local OEMs. XPeng and Li Auto both posted record October numbers with ~300% YoY growth, while NIO saw +60% YoY growth. BYD’s increased dominance in China is more visible with sales data by model: 5 of the top 6 highest selling models in October were BYD, combining for nearly 214,000-unit volume, compared to the Model Y’s 53,249 volume for the month.

China Sales, BYD vs Tesla

Source: I/O Fund

BYD has seen steady growth in NEV and purely BEV sales since May, and since June, BYD has posted five straight record months for NEV deliveries, rising from 253,046 in June to close out Q2 to more than301,000 in October to kick off Q4. Deliveries grew +39% YoY in October, the slowest growth rate so far this year, where monthly sales have averaged +77% YoY growth. In terms of BEV sales, for a more apples-to-apples comparison to Tesla, BYD recorded +60% YoY growth to 165,505 deliveries and exports of China-made vehicles in October – more than double Tesla’s total . At that rate, BYD is set to overtake Tesla in terms of quarterly BEV deliveries, being on track to surpass 500,000 BEVs in Q4, whereas Tesla is forecasting a volume of at least 449,000 vehicles in Q4 to reach its1.8 million target for 2023.

China Sales YoY Growth, BYD vs Tesla

Source: I/O Fund

On the other hand, Tesla’s China sales peaked in June at 93,680 vehicles, with September seeing a nearly (12%) MoM and (11%) YoY decline to 74,073 vehicles, including exports. October saw a fractional YoY increase of just +0.6% while registering a consecutive MoM decline of (2.6%), as the OEM continues to lag the growth of the broader NEV industry.

The Profitability Picture

NIO and XPeng are struggling to find a shift to profitability with elevated levels of R&D and losses piling up, whereas Tesla is facing margin troubles, exacerbated by its reliance on China. The reason here is simple: Tesla continues to sell vehicles in China below its average cost, from Q4 2022 through Q3 2023. Currently, the base Model Y is priced around $36,200, and the revamped Model 3 saw a 12% increase in its base price to $35,800 – both still below Tesla’s average cost of ~$37,487 per vehicle in Q3.

The recently announced Model Y price hikes may help alleviate the issue, given the Model Y is accounting for just over 70% of monthly sales in China, but the past four quarters have seen China’s ASP trail average cost per vehicle by (3%) or more.

Tesla's China ASP Below Average COGS Since Q4 2022

Source: I/O Fund

  • Q1 saw Tesla deliver 137,429 vehicles in China (excluding exports) for an average ASP of $35,589.
  • Q2 saw China’s ASP rise ~$1,000 to $36,578 on a +14% QoQ rise in deliveries to 156,676 vehicles. ASP was aided by a price increase in May and a higher mix of Model Y sales.
  • Q3 saw ASP decline once more to $35,953, as deliveries slipped (12.2%) QoQ to 139,624

Although Tesla has made progress in bringing its cost per vehicle lower over the past four quarters, ASP has declined at a quicker rate due to extensive price cuts. However, the sheer volume that China contributes – just under 33% of YTD deliveries at 433,729 vehicles – combined with ASP trailing average COGS means that Tesla’s margins will likely not recover above 20% until China’s ASP shifts back above average COGS. It is important for cost of goods sold (COGS) to be below average selling price (ASP), as the difference between the two is the gross profit. In Tesla’s case, China’s ASPs being below average COGS are weighing negatively on gross profit.

We previously discussed how Tesla will likely continue to lower prices to increase its leading EV market share to stave off competition which will intensify over the next few years. In a competitive analysis framework, we projected Tesla’s Q3 operating margins to decline to a level between Honda and VW, or to 7.8% compared to most recent 9.6%. Operating margin for Q3 was 7.6%, just below our base case and above our bearish case model. For a deeper dive into Tesla’s margin story is evolving, read more here and here.

Automotive Gross Margins

Source: I/O Fund

This is increasingly evident when looking at Tesla’s automotive gross margins. Automotive margin saw a pinch in Q2 2022 as COGS rose, before falling below 20% in Q4 2022 as China ASPs shifted below the COGS curve. Margins have fallen each quarter this year as China ASPs remains below the curve, dragging on global ASP which continues to slide as a result of price cuts.

However, BYD is showing strength in margins this year – BYD’s automotive gross margins surpassed 25% in Q3, rising from 20.7% in Q1 and from 22.8% in the year ago quarter. Automotive gross margin has also markedly improved from 15.6% in Q1 2022, an expansion of 1010 bp, while Tesla’s margins have contracted 1390 bp since peaking that same quarter at 29.65%. BYD has cut prices of some of its popular models, but not to the degree that it has become detrimental to margins.

Every Thursday at 4:30 pm Eastern, the I/O Fund team holds a webinar for premium members to discuss how to navigate the broad market, as well as various stock entries and exits. We offer trade alerts plus an automated hedging signal. The I/O Fund team is one of the only audited portfolios available to individual investors. Learn more here.

China’s Importance to Tesla

Tesla’s weaker sales numbers in China in September and October do raise some demand concerns, as these two months typically are the start of seasonal strength lasting through December. It also raises broader concerns within its margins and revenue growth, due to the outsized influence China has on Tesla’s production and deliveries.

Gigafactory Shanghai accounts for slightly more than half of Tesla’s current installed production capacity of ~1.85 million vehicles, with the plant capable of operating at a ~0.95 million annual run rate. Tesla noted in Q3 that the “Shanghai factory has been successfully running near full capacity for several quarters, and we do not expect a meaningful increase in weekly production run rate.” In Q3, Tesla sold 222,517 China-made vehicles, with 82,893 exported. On a YTD basis, Tesla sold 699,056 China-made vehicles, with 265,327 exported. That means China accounted for ~51.1% of Q3’s total deliveries and ~52.1% of the 1.32 million total deliveries YTD.

Shanghai is essentially maxed out in terms of the volume of vehicles that it can churn out, so October’s stagnation raises more questions about how Tesla will regain market share in China. With BYD’s strong growth in Q3 and Tesla’s slide in September, the American EV maker saw its market share fall more than 300 bp QoQ from 12.98% in Q2 to 9.89% in Q3.

While September’s MoM weakness could be chalked up to a production line upgrade in anticipation of the revamped Model 3, October’s MoM stagnation either points to a slowdown in production off full capacity at Giga Shanghai (annualized rate of ~0.86M vs ~0.95M max), or a build-up in China-made inventory. Neither scenario would be much of a positive for Tesla heading into China’s seasonally strong Q4, as both could suggest more demand weakness through the end of the year.

Conclusion

The main story for Tesla investors at the moment is when margins will bottom, as automotive and gross margin continues to deteriorate. China offers a major clue for when and where margins will bottom, given that Tesla relies on the country for about one-third of its deliveries and just over 20% of its revenues.

BYD is excelling at executing during this price-competitive time, with deliveries reaching a new monthly record while margins expand. On the other hand, Tesla has seen monthly sales in China stagnate, with ASP in the country sliding again in Q3. With China’s ASP currently going on five quarters below Tesla’s average COGS, the bottom for margins is still not in sight.

I/O Fund Equity Analyst Damien Robbins contributed to this report.

Recommended Reading:

Gains of up to 2,160% from our Free Newsletter.


Here are sample stock gains from the I/O Fund’s newsletter --- produced weekly and all for free!

2,160% on Nvidia

675% on Bitcoin

*as of Mar 27, 2025

Our newsletter provides an edge in the world’s most valuable industry – technology. Due to the enormous gains from this particular industry, we think it’s essential that every stock investor have a credible source who specializes in tech. Subscribe for Free Weekly Analysis on the Best Tech Stocks.

If you are a more serious investor, we have a premium service that offers lower entries and real-time trade alerts. Sample returns on the premium site include 3,430% on Nvidia, 915% on Chainlink, and 1,020% on Bitcoin. The I/O Fund is audited annually to prove it’s one of the best-performing Funds on the market, with returns that beat Wall Street funds.

beth
head bg

Get a bonus for subscription!

Subscribe to our free weekly stock
analysis and receive the "AI Stock: 5
Things Nobody is Telling you" brochure
for free.

More To Explore

Newsletter

Chart showing retail investor losses compared to institutional investors, highlighting market volatility and the impact of high-frequency trading.

The Harsh Truth: Retail Investors Take the Brunt of Market Losses

Retail investors face significant disadvantages in the stock market, often underperforming institutional investors by a wide margin. Studies show that high-frequency trading firms dominate market acti

March 28, 2025
Futuristic AI data center featuring NVIDIA’s GB200 Superchip, designed for AI superclusters, high-performance computing, and generative AI training with up to 27 trillion parameters.

NVIDIA’s GB200s for up to 27 Trillion Parameter Models: Scaling Next-Gen AI Superclusters

Supercomputers and advanced AI data centers are driving the AI revolution, enabling breakthroughs in deep learning and large-scale model training. As AI workloads become increasingly complex, next-gen

March 21, 2025
NVIDIA Blackwell Ultra GPU unveiled at GTC 2025, revolutionizing AI and HPC with unprecedented efficiency and power.

NVIDIA Blackwell Ultra Fuels AI & HPC Innovation, Efficiency and Capability  

NVIDIA’s latest Blackwell Ultra GPU, unveiled at NVIDIA GTC 2025, is transforming AI acceleration and high-performance computing (HPC). Designed for the “Age of Reasoning,” these cutting-edge GPUs del

March 21, 2025
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang discusses AI market dominance at GTC 2025, addressing demand concerns and future growth projections.

Nvidia CEO Predicts AI Spending Will Increase 300%+ in 3 Years

Nvidia has traversed choppy waters so far in 2025 as concerns have mounted about how the company plans to sustain its historic levels of demand. At GTC, Huang threw cold water on many of the Street’s

March 20, 2025
AI data centers are driving the AI revolution, but their soaring energy demands pose sustainability challenges. With power consumption projected to rise 160% by 2030, data centers are integrating brown, clean, and renewable energy sources. Goldman Sachs predicts 40% of new capacity will come from renewables, but can solar, wind, and nuclear sustain AI’s 24/7 operations? Explore how hyperscalers are evolving their energy strategies to meet growing AI demands.

AI Data Center Power Wars: Brown vs. Clean vs. Renewable Energy Sources

AI data centers are at the heart of the AI revolution, but their massive energy demands raise critical questions. With power consumption expected to grow 160% by 2030, data centers are turning to a mi

March 19, 2025
Natural gas pipelines supporting AI data centers as energy demand surges, with Texas and Louisiana emerging as key hubs for AI infrastructure growth.

Why Gas Pipelines Are the Unsung Heroes of AI Data Center Expansion

Natural gas is emerging as the backbone of AI data center expansion, with demand expected to reach up to 6 billion cubic feet per day by 2030. As AI-driven infrastructure surges, data centers are turn

March 19, 2025
Alibaba’s AI revenue growth accelerates, but remains significantly lower than U.S. tech leaders like Microsoft, highlighting China’s competitive AI landscape.

Alibaba Stock: China Has Low AI Revenue Compared to United States

Alibaba’s AI-driven cloud revenue is surging with six consecutive quarters of triple-digit growth. However, its AI earnings remain a fraction of what U.S. tech giants report, with Microsoft leading at

March 14, 2025
By 2030, AI data centers may consume 9% of U.S. electricity as GPU power usage surges, with Nvidia’s GB200 reaching 2,700W. To ensure sustainability, data centers are adopting long-term PPAs and exploring high-efficiency energy sources like nuclear and SOFCs.

Unlocking the Future of AI Data Centers: Which Fuel Source Reigns Supreme in Efficiency?

AI data centers are projected to consume 9% of U.S. electricity by 2030, driven by soaring GPU power demands, with Nvidia’s GB200 reaching 2,700W—a 300% increase over previous generations. As AI racks

March 13, 2025
Tesla faces declining deliveries in 2024 and mounting challenges in 2025, with sharp sales drops in China and Europe, margin pressures, and shifting growth targets.

Tesla Has a Demand Problem; The Stock is Dropping 

Tesla’s growth faces major hurdles in 2025 after its first annual decline in deliveries. Sales are plunging in key markets like China and Europe, while margins remain under pressure. Optimism around r

March 07, 2025
Stock market data with AI and crypto trends highlighted. I/O Fund provides institutional-grade stock analysis, offering insights on AI, semiconductors, and Bitcoin. Stay ahead with expert research and real-time trade transparency.

I/O Fund’s Top 10 of 2024

The digital world is overloaded with noise—millions of posts, comments, and messages flood the internet every minute. For investors, this creates a challenge: filtering out distractions to focus on hi

March 06, 2025
newsletter

Sign up for Analysis on
the Best Tech Stocks

https://bethtechnology.cdn.prismic.io/bethtechnology/e0a8f1ff-95b9-432c-a819-369b491ce051_Logo_Final_Transparent_IOFUND.svg
The I/O Fund specializes in tech growth stocks and offers in-depth research for Premium Members. Investors get access to a transparent portfolio, a forum, webinars, and real-time trade notifications. Sign up for Premium.

We are on social networks


Copyright © 2010 - 2025